Skip to main content

Understanding Tokens and max_tokens in AI APIs

When interacting with AI models like OpenAI's GPT through APIs, understanding how tokens work is essential for optimizing performance, controlling costs, and ensuring reliable responses—especially when generating code.

What Are Tokens?​

  • A token is a chunk of text: typically a word, part of a word, or punctuation.
  • Models process input (prompt tokens) and generate output (completion tokens) based on tokens.
  • Different models have different token limits (e.g., GPT-4 supports up to 128,000 tokens with certain configurations).

Examples:

  • "elephant" → 1 token
  • "unbelievable" → 2 tokens
  • "print(i)" → 6 tokens (each character or symbol might be a separate token)

What Is max_tokens?​

The max_tokens parameter controls the maximum number of tokens the model can generate in its response.

Key Points:​

  • It does not set a fixed length for the response.
  • It only limits the upper bound of the model’s reply.
  • The model stops generating when it:
    • Reaches a natural end
    • Hits a stop condition
    • Reaches the max_tokens limit

Why You Should Set max_tokens​

  1. Control Output Length: Prevent unexpectedly long replies.
  2. Manage Costs: You’re billed per token (input + output).
  3. Prevent Errors: Stay within the model’s total token limit.
  4. Predictable Behavior: Useful when generating responses of known complexity or length.

What If You Don’t Set max_tokens?​

  • The model may default to a high internal limit (which varies).
  • You risk:
    • Longer response times
    • Higher costs
    • Hitting context limits unintentionally

Why Code Uses More Tokens Than It Looks​

Even small code snippets can consume many tokens due to their structure and syntax.

Reasons:​

  • High token density: Each symbol, keyword, or indent is often its own token.
  • Formatting overhead: Line breaks, indentation, comments, and structure increase tokens.
  • Prompt instructions: Asking for detailed logging, comments, or multiple features inflates output.

Example:

for i in range(10):
    print(i)

This is just 3 lines, but consumes about 10 tokens or more.

Best Practices​

GoalRecommendation
Short responseSet low max_tokens and prompt with “briefly”
Long detailed responseSet higher max_tokens (e.g., 800–1000)
Cost controlUse a hard max_tokens ceiling
Flexible repliesSet a generous limit and let the model decide
Generating codeBe concise in prompts and limit verbosity

Pro Tip: Estimate Token Usage​

Use libraries like tiktoken to estimate the number of tokens in your prompt and plan your max_tokens accordingly.

Summary​

  • Tokens are the currency of AI models.
  • max_tokens sets a limit, not a target.
  • Code is visually short but token-dense.
  • Set max_tokens to balance cost, performance, and quality.

By managing tokens wisely, you can fine-tune the behavior and efficiency of your AI-powered applications.